PMS – an explanation?

I have to give credit to my Dad for finding this piece of useful information. (He asked me not to share it with Jock – I can see why after reading it. Jock, don’t read this entry below.)

Side Note: I apologize in advance for the content of this piece as it may offend certain people (ah hem, some men or women who have no interest in the woman’s reproductive cycles.) However, I find this extremely relevant to my situation, and how to deal with life in general – which is, in fact, what this blog is mostly about. Thank you for the feedback though!

A variety of evolutionary rationales for the syndrome have been offered, including that it is an epiphenomenon due to the selective advantage accruing to other phases of the hormonal cycle,[11] that it leads to “intensification of male ardour during the next onset of fertility”,[12] and that it prompts females to reject infertile males (who cause PMS due to not impregnating the female). “… an infertile male/potentially fertile female partnership would tend to break down, thus allowing a new pair-bond to be formed. The greater the degree of premenstrual hostility of the female, the sooner a fertile mating could ensue.”[13] Any theory would have to account for the persistence of PMS over substantial evolutionary time, as it appears to afflict baboons as well.[14] ~Wikipedia

I have some problems with the excerpt (mostly that I don’t want a baby right now!), but it makes sense on an evolutionary scale. Hey, at least it’s something. The wording is a bit hefty, but the gist of it can be understood.

I’m really getting into this PMS research – hey, knowledge is power. So, perhaps the more I know about it, the more I’ll be able to control it.

The only problem is that the more research I do, the more I realize that actually, no one has a fecking clue what causes it! Heck, even women who have their uterus removed still get it. The one thing they do know is that it comes along with menstruating. Brilliant!

If you’d like to read some more, here’s a paper written in 1992, and printed in the Social Science and Medicine. Click here for the full article.

Abstract-In 1931 a physician coined the term Premenstrual Tension, thereby commencing an extensive biomedical inquiry into the relationship between women’s menstrual cycle and the occurrence of physical, emotional and behavioral changes. However, despite 58 years of scientific research, fundamental questions remain unanswered. For example, there is still no consensus on the definition of PMS. This, in turn, has led to disagreement among researchers about which medical specialty is best suited for diagnosing and treating PMS. Is PMS a disease whose pathology is best understood by physicians in reproductive medicine or in psychiatry?

This paper argues that the inconclusiveness surrounding PMS is symptomatic of the persistence of cultural beliefs in the production (and reproduction) of medical knowledge. The roots of these cultural beliefs and their ‘naturalness’ in the context of Western ideas about reason, rationality and women are explored in the first section. The second section discusses the ubiquity of these same cultural beliefs in contemporary scientific research of PMS and in the controversy surrounding the proposed psychiatric diagnostic category of Late Luteal Phase Dysphoric Disorder (LLPDD). Finally, a new, anthropologically and sociologically informed approach to understanding the phenomenon of PMS is suggested.

Another person he suggested reading is Camille Paglia. Might just order her book.

Thanks Dad, for teaching me more about PMS!

Bookmark and Share

Related posts:

  1. PMS – Pain in My Sass I’m thinking about PMS today (or PMT – premenstrual tension,...
  2. Last 14 Days of Searches These are some of the Google searches that people have...
  3. The Beginning of the Beginning Finding the start of my book is exciting even if...
  4. Before Its Gone People say you don’t know what you’ve got until it’s...
  5. Representative of the USA I re-read a few of my emails from when I...
This entry was posted in Personal and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Hanna
    I just have one thought on all of this. Why did women get the seriously short-end of the stick with every issue known to humans? Just not fair , I say. And since I'm past the point of PMS, I have another whole new set of issues. Girls... it never ends! Argh!!!
  • No, don't suspect it does stop. On the other hand, men can't multi-task nor can they experience how great it is to be a woman! I would never want to give up how much I feel things or the joy of being a daughter. Or the ability to change my hair style as much as I want. Or the wardrobe - men just don't have as good of choices as we do. For those things and more, I will always be grateful. I would never want to be a man!
  • Lindsey Bauer
    Meagan,

    After thinking about the PMS/PMT thing and doing some brief wiki-ing myself I decided to post a comment. So there are (absolutely) changes which happen during times of a given month and are linked to a woman's menstrual cycle, yes. I tend never to use this state of affairs as a way to reduce/explain/defend behaviors, reflections or feelings because I think it potentially adds to the hype of it all. I am pro-active in my approach to living- diet, exercise, balance, B vitamins, etc. I also truly believe in the self-fulfilling prophecy. I am a teacher- so of course. If you believe in something and expect certain behaviors, odds are those behaviors will manifest. I don't have anything less expected for the performance of my body. So perhaps another perspective is to meet this challenge eye to eye, or red lipstick for that matter- pro-activity and diminished power of the age old unexplainable pest. xoxo _L
  • Hi Lindz!
    Welcome to the blog commenting world :)
    You know, that's a really interesting theory, and something I will definitely take into consideration. Because, yes, once I realize the thoughts that are entering my mind are extremely negative, I do decide to try to change it. On the other hand, I don't like to use it as an excuse for that reason - would never want to help out the hype - on the other hand, if it does help explain my sudden outbursts - I'll take it. I don't see any reason to be hard on myself about it.
    Another thought for me - I have noticed an increased degree of PMS since I got an IUD inserted (not to mention the cramps that I've never had before)...I think this may explain some of it as well.
    I'm going to stop expecting it - that's the biggest thing I take from your comment. Really well thought out. Thanks!!
  • jenny monster
    How timely meg-o! I've got some serious PMS right this second! Its amazing how some days I think I may be going completely crazy, then I stop and look at the calendar and let out a big sigh of relief! Stay ten feet away...thats my general rule!
  • It's true - I end up feeling completely insane - like the world will end, and everything in my life is horrible. The mind - a dangerous thing!
  • i have read a similar explanation to the one your dad gave you...i've also read that it is more of a cultural evolution.
    either way it sucks!
    i really cut back on high sodium foods during this super fun time, as well as amp up my calcium. also, lemon verbena tea. i swear it is a miracle worker for all things related to PMS! i started drinking it a few months ago and i swear by it for PMS stuff.
  • My mom actually mentioned the cultural evolution theory - that certain foods can affect us, etc. You know, that's a great idea! I will try Lemon Verbena! I love that tea, and do drink it as often as I can (especially after a big night out, so why not during PMS?)
  • Umm, interesting. i assumed that their would be some explanation for it already figured out but it seems we are all in the dark on it really.
  • Yeah, maybe it's up to us to decide!
  • Very well written as always M.
  • Haha. Feeling much better than I did last night. Thank you. At least I could find it in myself to type this blog post.
    How was she?
  • So Meagan, how are you feeling today? ;)
    I saw Paglia in person on my college campus back in the 90's.
    She took part in a political forum.
blog comments powered by Disqus